
For years I struggled with this recipe. First of all the recipes I used seemed over complicated, and more importantly, in these 'fat' conscious healthy days, quite fatty. Then because of the method involved, the potatoes took too long to cook, and the end result was never quite 'right'.
However, I came across a recipe on the Internet (hey, I never pretend any of my recipes are original), all credit to Skye Gyngell, from The Independent newspaper, for this gem.
Previously I had peeled and sliced the potatoes very thinly, I then buttered the dish, grated the cheese, poured the cream.............and found out after a few hours of the prescribed cooking time, the potato slices were still hard.
Here follows Skye's brilliantly easy recipe. I cooked this yesterday evening - to accompany some excellent Scottish Sirloin Steaks, a green salad, together with sliced fried mini portabello mushrooms and red onions, and some oven baked beer battered onion rings with black peppercorns.
The excellent thing about this potato dish is you can cook it earlier, and just re-heat in the oven.
So here goes.
Sorry, I have no photos apart from the one above from the internet, my eldest son was back for the weekend, and between the three of us, well, it kinda disappeared!
This recipe serves 6 so I cut down the quantities a wee bit, obviously as there were only 3 of us, and to be honest, I did not use double cream (is this called "heavy" cream in the States??) - I used single cream, still good though as a substitution.
12 Desiree Potatoes (I used Rooster potatoes, but any red skinned older potato will do, plus King Edwards are brilliant)
1 pint of full fat milk (because I watch my fat intake, I used semi-skimmed milk - it makes no difference to the end result)
sea salt and ground black pepper
3 cloves of garlic, peeled and finely sliced
1 and 1/2 teaspoons of fresh grated nutmeg (you cannot leave this magic ingredient out of this dish!)
400ml double cream (here I substituted single cream, no difference in the outcome of the recipe)
175g/6oz Gruyere cheese, grated (use nothing but Gruyere, however, if you really have to substitute, use Emmental) - it needs to be a real nutty cheese. Cheddar is way too fatty.
2oz Parmesan, grated.
I also added a finely chopped onion to the mix, but it is up to personal taste. My original recipe included onion, so I stuck with it.
Heat the oven to 200c/400F/Gas Mark 6. Peel and finely slice the potato into rounds about 3mm or eighth of an inch thick. Rinse slices of potato under cold water although don't let them soak in water for any length of time as this removes all the starch.
Now this is the magical and easy part of this recipe. Where I used to layer the uncooked potato in the baking dish and add the remaining ingredients, and then wait ages for the potato to cook in the oven, oh no...................
Place the potato slices in a saucepan and cover with the milk, top up with a little water if necessary and add some salt to taste (we are fairly salt less peeps, so I go easy on the salt - my maxim being you can always add it later). Place over a low heat and simmer gently for 20 mins or until the potatoes are tender when pierced with a fork.
(Now Jeannie disaster zone here, milk seems to boil quicker than water so keep an eye on the saucepan, mine boiled over while I went upstairs to check on the computer........;0(, and made a mess of the hob and I had some burnt potatoes stuck to the bottom of the pan - I am being nothing but honest, but you learn from mistakes.)
Also because I used Rooster potatoes (from Ireland and Scotland), they cook quickly, so if using a quick cook potato like this variety, reduce the cooking time. Important though wherever you source your potatoes, to choose a floury potato.
Drain and place potatoes in a bowl. Mine were too overcooked so I did not do this, I simply drained them and placed the resulting "Almost Jeannie Disaster but not quite, nearly mash" in a baking dish ready for the rest of the ingredients to be added and for baking in the oven. I used a Pyrex shallow, glass lasagna dish, sadly not one of the glamorous designs from the 60s and 70s, Joe's Mum, collects!
Add the garlic, nutmeg, cream and salt and pepper. Toss to mix well, (to be honest I just layered the rest of the ingredients on top as my potatoes were so soft!) Taste and adjust seasoning.
This dish should be substantial in flavour, not insipid, you are looking for a distinctly garlicky, nutmegy flavour.
Once the dish is layered up and the taste to your satisfaction, cover with the grated Gruyere cheese and Parmesan. Finish with a couple of turns of the pepper mill and place in the heated oven. Cook until golden and bubbling. Approximately 25 mins. Serve immediately.
The difference from my old recipes..............the cooking of the potato slices first (although slightly overcooked this time), plus no butter. My recipes for this used to be full of butter, greasing the dish, and adding butter in flecks on top of the potato.
Also, what has greatly helped me this weekend with my cooking, is my new and rather magical possession. In nearly 32 years of cooking for a family, I have never owned a food processor. In the recent closing down sales of our beloved Woolworths, I managed to pick up a Kenwood Food Processor FP120 Series for the measly sum of £18.
It chops, slices, squeezes lemons and oranges, mixes and grates.................and I think I may be in love!
Before 9 am this morning, I had made a wonderful vegetable soup, plus a Smoked Mackerel Pate, which has been devoured this lunchtime.
Somehow I think my two boys will be coming home even more regularly than usual at this rate.